Coterie Pizza

9.23.2023: We finally made it back to Coterie Pizza and loved that every bit as much as the first time that we visited. We try to couple of different pizzas. We ordered the pepperoni sausage, spinach artichoke, mushroom medley, and hot honey pizzas. One of us also ordered a salad and thought it was very good! I still highly recommend this place no matter where you are in Fort Wayne or the surrounding areas. We visited Coterie Pizza in Garrett this weekend and I have to say that that was really impressed. Here's the TLDR as this review might get little long. Here are the two things you need to know. 1. The pizza is outstanding. 2. Self-serve beer wall. If you want to stop reading at this point and just go visit I don't blame you. We decided to get four pizzas so we could taste as many as we could. We got the Cajun, Brisket, Mushroom Medley and Chicken Bruschetta. All four of them were very good and each of them were very flavorful in their own ways. The one thing that we found all of that pizza had in common was the amazing crust. The crust was perfectly cooked, it was the perfect blend of chewiness and crispness. The pizza was even very good cold as leftovers. It was very chewy cold BUT the thinness and airiness makes it easy to eat. If you're still reading you won't be disappointed. The other really amazing thing about this place was that they had a serve-yourself-pay-by-the-ounce beer/wine/cider wall. I personally have never seen anything like it. There are ten taps total. With 5 touch screen controls in which you select the beverage that you want. The screen shows you how much per ounce do you will be paying and then you scan and electronic wristband and start pouring! Screen shows you how many ounces you've poured and then you enjoy! At the end of the day you have them scan your wristband and they add the cost of what you consumed to your bill. It was a very unique experience and that combined with the amazing Pizza has me pining to go back as soon as possible. One thing I found out that they could improve upon is that I'm not sure that there's any way to know what beverages they have on tap before you get there. I do not believe they are on the Untappd website yet but I did suggest that they take a look at that so that patrons could get an idea what they were serving before they got there. I highly recommend this place and plan to be making the trip up from Fort Wayne again as soon as possible.

Coterie dine in. My girlfriend and I visited here for dinner one day. We ordered the sausage and pepperoni pizza, beer cheese, and breadsticks and sampled some draft from the beer wall. Coterie has a few standout features. The beer wall is the first I've seen of its kind, scan your band, and pour your beer of choice, in a glass of choice, by yourself. Creative idea that makes the experience a lot of fun. The wooden decor is pleasing, but sound travels well inside, and it's usually very loud even without a lot of patrons. The staff were friendly and attentive. The beer cheese and bread were a definite highlight. They were incredible. The pizza was very good, but not the best I've ever had. The breakdown: The crust, absolutely perfect. Very good flavor and some crispness, but not too much. The cheese is good overall. The pepperoni and sausage were good but nothing spectacular. The sauce wasn't very good, it tastes of fresh tomatoes, and that's about it, which leaves a lot of traditional pizza sauce flavor to be desired. I would give it an honest 8.9/10. It is a great place to visit, and it's worth the drive if you're coming from Fort Wayne. The cost for our drinks, pizza, and appetizer only rang out to around $40, which is fairly affordable, I feel.

Great little spot just North of the Fort! Excellent pizza selection, awesome crust, and the price is right. Highlight of this location is the "self serve" beer wall, where you scan in with the provided bracelet, and pour yourself a pint...or do a couple ounces of each and create your own flight! Tap registers your pour, and the price per ounce goes straight to your tab!

We ordered the Cajun pizza, pretty good, with plenty of heat. Sauce was gritty and not smooth. Also ordered the pepperoni hot honey pizza and it was good. The couple with us had to go to the counter and wait in line to get their salad that didn't come, they were almost done with their meal when it came in a to go box. Plenty of room inside, food court atmosphere, did not like the beer wall concept with limited choices. All in all good food and friendly staff, good prices.